Tuesday, 7 May 2024

All Engines Go! Review - S3 Ep.7 - Duck Duck Whoosh!

 THESE ARE MY OWN OPINIONS AND ARE NOT INFLUENCED FROM THE THOMAS & FRIENDS FANBASE

DUCK DUCK WHOOSH!
Written by
Allan Neuwrith 

Directed by
Campbell Bryer 

Produced by
Suzie Gallo

Air Date
24/02/24 - CAN
7/03/24 - US

Plot
Kana wants to go extra fast, but Sodor's tracks are too twisty; to help, the engines lay some straight tracks that accidentally lead to a watery place.

Throughout the episode, all I kept saying was 'Build-A-Bridge!' literally a straight bridge that could go over the duck pond, clearly an easy win-win solution to the problem that Kana and the others were facing. Kana can go fast as ever and the pond will stay in tact with the animals. Yes it would be inconsistent but this is AEG, inconsistency is never a problem! I guess they want to push for an enviornmental episode but a bridge would not harm anyone! 

The rest of the episode was boring and the song is just worth skipping through.  

Series Rating:
What's the Buzz - 4.5/10
Bells are Ringing - 4/10
Abraca-Diesel - 2/10
Overcommitted - 2.5/10
Sandy's Fine Mess - 4/10
Nia's Green Surprise - 3/10
Duck Duck Whoosh! - 1/10

Overall Rating (So far):
20/70


Monday, 6 May 2024

All Engines Go! Review - S3 Ep.6 - Nia's Green Surprise

 THESE ARE MY OWN OPINIONS AND ARE NOT INFLUENCED FROM THE THOMAS & FRIENDS FANBASE

NIA'S GREEN SURPRISE
Written by
Jaya Ramdath

Directed by
Campbell Bryer 

Produced by
Suzie Gallo

Air Date
17/02/24 - CAN
7/03/24 - US

Plot
A floral delivery has the engines racing to take care of the unique plant.

You think with an engine from India that knows about the plant that Nia was given to in the mail that maybe she knows where it needs to placed and what it needs in order for it to grow? Why not have Ashima, who is suppose to be the adult character here, to teach the young engines about it maybe to give the message to read the instructions so you can understand more or listen to other people who had more experience with things instead of making her ignorant. Have the engines try to find things to make the plant grow until they realise when Ashima brought them the instructions they threw out.

The rest of the episode is just the usual standard, all the engines have to go on a wild goose chase for something with obstacles in the way contridicting things such as them having the power to jump off the rails and roll on the ground that was already established and then they get the item back in the most anti-climatic way possible. Nothing new, nothing exciting, nothing interesting. It was boring. 

Series Rating:
What's the Buzz - 4.5/10
Bells are Ringing - 4/10
Abraca-Diesel - 2/10
Overcommitted - 2.5/10
Sandy's Fine Mess - 4/10
Nia's Green Surprise - 3/10

Overall Rating (So far):
19/60


Sunday, 5 May 2024

All Engines Go! Review - S3 Ep.5 - Sandy's Fine Mess

 THESE ARE MY OWN OPINIONS AND ARE NOT INFLUENCED FROM THE THOMAS & FRIENDS FANBASE

SANDY'S FINE MESS
Written by
Adam Beechen

Directed by
Campbell Bryer 

Produced by
Suzie Gallo

Air Date
17/02/24 - CAN
7/03/24 - US

Plot
With her friends' help, Sandy discovers new uses for her treasured junk.

I like how Sandy comes off as a bit of hoarder when it comes to her stuff but the whole plotline of finding new uses for her stuff is almost the same from what we've seen in 'Something Broken, Someone Blue' when Thomas lost his friend Boxy after he'd accidently destroyed it. But was repurposed into something different in the end. Sandy has an emotional connection with her stuff that she would find useful for something later which is kinda like how Thomas loved Boxy as a playmate. 

Maybe instead of Sandy being a hoarder, you can have her collecting all the stuff until there was not enough space. Have her going through that denial that she has too much stuff until she realises and knew that most of the stuff she'd collected is basically nothing that's worth it. You could even use the part when they went to recycling plant to bring the story home of where you can take stuff you want to get rid of. 

While Sandy and Thomas had different encounters, the whole episode just feels the same and speaking of the recycling plant it was also strange seeing how Thomas and Sandy discovered that Whiff's recycling plant can repurpose things despite that last season we've seen them knowing it in things such as the Lookout Mountain special. While there are many different writers of the show, I wish that AEG has someone on the team that keeps its consistency in check to avoid contridictions. 

 Series Rating:
What's the Buzz - 4.5/10
Bells are Ringing - 4/10
Abraca-Diesel - 2/10
Overcommitted - 2.5/10
Sandy's Fine Mess - 4/10

Overall Rating (So far):
16/50


Saturday, 4 May 2024

All Engines Go! Review - S3 Ep.4 - Overcommitted

 THESE ARE MY OWN OPINIONS AND ARE NOT INFLUENCED FROM THE THOMAS & FRIENDS FANBASE

OVERCOMMITTED
Written by
Sarah Eisenberg
Becky Wangberg

Directed by
Campbell Bryer 

Produced by
Suzie Gallo

Air Date
10/02/24 - CAN
7/03/24 - US

Plot
Thomas tries to be in two places at once so he doesn't disappoint his friends.

This episode was boring with the whole character being overcommitted storyline that was already done in other kids shows in whatever situation. It's not bad to teach kids this sort of stuff but it just doesn't feel unique. Part of the original series' charm was its railway aspect. Despite the characters having human characteristics, they are suppose to be steam engines in the end. Machines whose primary purpose were to work. That's unique and you could try many different scenarios with it that could make it work logically. 

While this episode had Thomas making deliveries while trying to be with Kana I just close my eyes and see this with human characters that could be doing the same thing but maybe as truck drivers or as postman etc. doing the same thing with the same outcome like the episode. Perhaps to make it more railway unique is to have Thomas or anyother engine helping out with the other engines with passengers and trucks but also has to balance out their own work and realising that he was overworking himself until the Fat Controller found out about it. 

I know we had 'Thomas' Crazy Day' but even that episode, despite its railway nature, make the characters feel more like a human than an engine. 

Series Rating:
What's the Buzz - 4.5/10
Bells are Ringing - 4/10
Abraca-Diesel - 2/10
Overcommitted - 2.5/10

Overall Rating (So far):
12/40


Friday, 3 May 2024

All Engines Go! Review - S3 Ep.3 - Abraca-Diesel

  THESE ARE MY OWN OPINIONS AND ARE NOT INFLUENCED FROM THE THOMAS & FRIENDS FANBASE

ABRACA-DIESEL
Written by
Peter Gaffeny

Directed by
Campbell Bryer 

Produced by
Suzie Gallo

Air Date
10/02/24 - CAN
7/03/24 - US

Plot
After his magic trick goes wrong, Diesel learns a greater power: friendship.

I think what could've been better for this episode to make it more engaging is if you let Diesel and Sandy have an argument that resulted in her 'disappearance'. Perhaps Sandy wanted to be the magician but Diesel refused because he wanted to do it which would result in Sandy tricking him and sneaking away to make Diesel look bad only for her to realise that she had been a 'bad friend' because she made Diesel worried and over something silly. You can also have Diesel to learn his lesson that he was also bad for not letting Sandy being the magician which results in them having them being not in right over their behaviour. However the end result for this episode lacks that. There was nothing that made me feel sorry for Diesel when Sandy was helping James and Carly. The episode was bad.

You had 'Letting off Steam' from the first season that showcased Thomas and Percy getting into an argument and there wasn't even a peep from anybody, to my knowledge, who were aghast at two best friends having an argument. It happens in real life for kids, are some of the writers afraid that it might be the case of bad influence or something? A story without any conflict between characters is just dry, bland and tasteless. 

The song is just the usual. A generic song with friendship slapped all over it that has little to do with whatever the episode was trying to say. Its lyrics are just so bland and the song was just not needed for the story. 

Series Rating:
What's the Buzz - 4.5/10
Bells are Ringing - 4/10
Abraca-Diesel - 2/10

Overall Rating (So far):
10.5/30

Thursday, 2 May 2024

All Engines Go! Review - S3 Ep.2 - Bells are Ringing

 THESE ARE MY OWN OPINIONS AND ARE NOT INFLUENCED FROM THE THOMAS & FRIENDS FANBASE

BELLS ARE RINGING
Written by
Tracy Nicoletti 

Directed by
Campbell Bryer 

Produced by
Suzie Gallo

Air Date
3/02/24 - CAN
7/03/24 - US

Plot
Percy's lucky bell is missing, so he and Thomas try to solve the mystery of its disappearance.

I think they should've made Percy more angry here since his lucky bell meant so much to him. It might not fit with the vibe that is AEG but when it comes to the engines being depicted as kids, kids can get angry when something they value something as precious goes missing and get very emotional over it. Why not make Percy angry and falsely accusing the others for taking his bell away, or so he thought, until he realised his own mistake at the end of the episode. 

They should show characters that kids are suppose to look up too with flaws which helps them to grow and learn, that's what made the original series of Thomas very popular in the first place. The episode itself is another alright but not great story and I wish they did it better.

 
Series Rating:
What's the Buzz - 4.5/10
Bells are Ringing - 4/10

Overall Rating (So far):
8.5/20


Wednesday, 1 May 2024

All Engines Go! Review - S3 Ep.1 - What's the Buzz

 Season 3 of AEG made its debut back in February 2024 in Canada, home of Nelvana, the production house where 'All Engines Go!' is animated. There is really not much to go off from for the show's third season except for the fact that it is now 26 episodes long like the original series and that to sign the season off we will be having a 60min special based around on Christmas, a major first for the franchise, called 'The Christmas Letter Express' written by Rick Suvalle who hadn't written an episode since the show's first episode back in 2021. But I'm not looking forward to it as after watching the last two 60 minute specials and seeing how they turned out, I feel it'll be another very long exhausting special with unmemorable songs to fill in time and I believe there would be not much marketing behind it from Mattel's side until it's close to its release date. But that special is another post for another day.

Season 2 of AEG was a slight improvement to its first season but overall, the former, like the latter, was very underwhelming in my opinion. Sure all my reviews is not going to bring the original series back but that was never the point to begin with. It is basically trying to look at these episode without a non-biased lens and see why they are either good or bad and what could've been better storywise and maybe someone from either Mattel or the writing staff might find these but I'm just a guy with a small blogsite. 

Recently, I've seen people trying to use the excuse that the show is 'just made for kids' and that excuse just feels like a total brush off to shut people up who are very critical of this series. People have been very critcal about BWBA and the rest of the original series over the years, including the books, that it just feels hypocritical and also just because it is a kids show doesn't mean that quality was put into it. Ever wonder why Bluey is so popular not just with kids but to adults as well who either have kids of their own or who are grandparents, aunts, uncles? And it's not just adults but teenagers as well!

One of the best things about Bluey is that it has some stories that deal with tough subjects that the older audience can understand but with total nuance towards children. The episode where Chillie's sister can't have children because she was infertile is one episode I can think of from the top of my head that has that and explain it to a child in a way they could understand which was Bluey wanting the onesie that Bingo was wearing. It was a beautiful and emotional episode, especially for adults who are actually going through with it. The only AEG episode that has that was the episode from S2 with Boxy being turned into something different. But the rest of the series, to me, AEG, was generic, loud, morally forced and comedically forced dribble, to an extent.

However berating people who are fans of the iteration of Thomas is something that I condem because at the end of the day people have different tastes and see things differently unlike maybe a majority and we must respect their individuality. Sure I might not agree with what they say but I won't go as far as berating their intelligence, unlike some people on this crazy, very broken, chatoic world known as the internet. And I have more sympathy for fans of AEG because as someone who actually enjoys BWBA, despite its problems, I understand the annoyance of being belittled by some who have a complete meltdowns over someone liking something that they don't.  

But enough rambling, maybe Season 3 might be better but I'm starting off this season with extremely low expectations. But thankfully it's 26 episodes rather than 52, but still split in half. So here are my views of S3A, but first:

THESE ARE MY OWN OPINIONS AND ARE NOT INFLUENCED FROM THE THOMAS & FRIENDS FANBASE

WHAT'S THE BUZZ
Written by
John Loy

Directed by
Campbell Bryer 

Produced by
Suzie Gallo

Air Date
3/02/24 - CAN
7/03/24 - US

Plot
When bees settle on Thomas' funnel, he seeks a better home for them.

Surprisingly, after seeing two mediocre and dissapointing season openers, this one was actually alright. Not bad or great, just average. It feels almost like an episode that could work in the original series, I know we had 'Buzzy Bees' back in 2010 and after watching the latter for the first time in years, while reviewing this episode to see if the plots are similar, which thankfully is not because this episode was much better with its pacing and unlike the 2010 episode it had more of a story instead of a formula, despite the three strikes formula in this episode. 

The song however is just, you guessed it, another bland forgettable song which is about not giving up. The messages these songs tell us are what's not bad. What's bad about them is that I feel they don't allow the audience to digest the message themselves because it feels like they need to telling them what it is. Kids are more smarter than you think and society should never underestimate them. 

 This episode was just moderate but not very memorable, like any episode of AEG. It's a moderate start to S3A but expectations are still very low.

And despite me mentioning 'Buzzy Bees', no it doesn't mean I'll be re-reviewing S13-16 anytime in the future. After sitting through that episode to see if the plots are similar, they had never aged well.    

Series Rating:
What's the Buzz - 4.5/10

Overall Rating (So far):
4.5/10