Saturday, 21 November 2026

CGI Series Re-Review: Season 13 (2010)

 The last time I'd done a re-review of the CGI era of the show was back in 2021. I'd avoided S13-16 at the time because I wasn't interested in rewatching the whole era again with all of its problems. Well, I think enough time had passed to sit through these again, along with the season's specials that were released alongside, despite my memories of these things still fresh in my mind. But like I said in my review of All Engines Go! If there's a bad episode I'll say it's bad but if there's a good one I'll say it's good and should leave my bias aside to look at these in a fair but critical viewpoint. So before we dive into Series 13, here's some history:

 In 2008, HIT Entertainment had announced that the models will be retired in favour of CGI animation due to cost cutting measures and maximisation of profits, thanks to taxation and government tax breaks for UK animation at the time and quite interestingly, the existence of 'Chuggington'. When HIT Entertainment saw the pilot of the show in 2006 they were worried that Thomas would become obsolete. Interesting how in the end, Thomas is still going despite its ups and downs while Chuggington faded away into obscurity by the early 2010's until it fizzled out after its fifth season in 2015 and even its attempt at a reboot around 2020 led to nowhere too and the only country that is still showing Chuggington is Japan, and they went hard on it all to the point they had outlines at a light rail in Okayama city.

 The animation would be provided by Nitrogen Studios, now called Cinesite Vancouver, a production company from Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada, and was to be directed by Greg Tiernan, who is a superfan of the Railway Series books. With the transformation of the show from live action models to CGI, there was to be some firsts such as the characters adding more expressions, humans were reinstated since S8 as there movement are now limitless and a full voice cast for the engines, and that one was a massive change in the show's history as the voices were once provided by a storyteller alone. Prior to this Japan was the only well-known country to give the show a voice cast.

 The CGI era of Thomas debuted to the world in Canada on September 6th, 2009 when 'Hero of the Rails' aired on television and would be followed by its DVD release two days later in the North American market. Series 13 would then make its debut on October 26th that same year via Screenopsis, don't know what that is, and later theatrically in November that year in the US and then it would make its TV debut in the UK in January 2010 kicking off the 65th anniversary year. With the series now over 15 years old, does it still hold up? Is the series really that bad the way fandom made it out to be? Well, let's find out. But first the usual:

THESE ARE SOLEY MY OPINIONS AND ARE NOT INFLUENCED FROM THE THOMAS & FRIENDS FANBASE

 SERIES 13

Written by

Sharon Miller
Mark Robertson
Allan Plenderleith
David Richard Fox
Miranda Larson
Robyn Charteris
Louise Kramskoy
Alan Hescott

 

Directed by
Greg Tiernan

 

Produced by
Nicole Stinn
 
Told by
Michael Angelis (UK)
Michael Brandon (US)
 
EPISODES
 
CREAKY CRANKY
Written by Sharon Miller
A crane lifting a train

AI-generated content may be incorrect.
 
One of the major problems that this season, as well as the special, had faced was the constant yammering of the storyteller telling us every detail such as how the characters were feeling or where they were going or what they were doing. In the days of the model era this could be excused because of the static model faces and limitations of the props and all. But now with the show transformed into full CGI, there was no need for it, and it gets really annoying because there was no time for the storyteller to pause and take a breath or even just not talk at all. I have nothing but respect towards the late Michael Angelis, since I was watching the UK dub, but man there were times that I just wanted him to really stop talking.
 
Is it really that hard to have the moment where Cranky, at the climax of the episode, broke down after lifting Thomas without the need of him telling us what we can hear and see? Do they really think we won’t know what’s going on? Kids are smarter than what society gives them credit for. Do we really need to know how Thomas and Cranky are feeling when we can see the expression on their faces? Do we really know that Thomas chuffed away or chuffed back to the docks? Do we really need them to tell us the moral instead of letting the story itself tell the moral itself in a show don’t tell manner? No we don’t because we can clearly see it happening! Show don’t tell!

This is why I’m glad that the production team from S17-24 had decreased the usage of the storyteller from S19. We didn’t need the storyteller in ‘Who’s Geoffrey?’ to tell us that Thomas was worried or that he was racing away from his problems because he didn’t want to get into trouble because we know that visually. I’ve seen some people on the internet trying to disparage the Brenner era of the show nowadays for some reason and would try to defend this era as some misunderstood masterpiece, they’re far from it. The Brenner/McCue era has its shortcomings like the characterisations and all, but after seeing stuff like this, it made me appreciate the Brenner/McCue era much more. Unlike this era, they actually try to improve the show and experiment with different ideas.
 
The exposition at the start of the episodes where the engines were preparing for the Duke and Duchess' spring festival at their summer house was so pointless and unneeded because it barely had any importance in the episode with nothing at stake. If you replace it with something generic like the engines like to be very busy and have Henry and James pulling their loads for the farms instead of the Boxford’s, nothing will change plot wise you would have the same story and same outcome. With this episode being the start of the CG era of Thomas, what a disappointing way to start it off and just imagine if this was the first thing people saw instead of ‘Hero of the Rails’? The 2009 special really tries to sell you the justification of Thomas being in CGI with swooping camera angles, weight of the engines and all. It’s not perfect, and I will get to that later on, but that was a smart decision by HIT at the time to showcase that first instead of this episode.
 
If one was to improve the episode’s story you could make it Cranky being sensitive because his cables were getting old and they began to creak and groan, Thomas eggs him on when he saw he could only lift lighter loads and Cranky full with pride refuse to be put down by a steam engine until it was all too late and he snapped his crane arm resulting in him being damaged and Thomas trapped and he has to stay there as punishment for his silliness and Cranky learnt to not shy away from telling everyone about his problem. Sure it might sound the same but if the run time was shorter compared to the 11 min run time they were going for it could make for a much better story without the pointless filler to pad out time.

This was also the season where Matt Wilkinson had voiced Victor before David Bedella, who’d voiced him in the US dub, took over from him in the UK dub in 2012. Looking back, I much prefer Bedella’s voice as it’s nice and soothing, especially that he was to be the train-coded doctor. Matt Wilkinson while he’s a great voice actor feels like he was just giving Victor an exaggerated accent and that’s it. It doesn’t matter what country he was supposed to be from, they just wanted an exaggerated accent.
 
There was also one scene that I disliked, and it was when Thomas returned to the docks from the steamworks. The shot (below) could work for an establishing shot when it comes to the opening of an episode or maybe if Thomas was coming from the other side. But it just feels awkward because Thomas is tucked away in the corner and not focused on him returning to the docks. Nitrogen Studios had done some good direction, but this is one of their blunders. All in all a very weak start to the CGI era of Thomas.

Rating:
1/10
 
THE LION OF SODOR
Written by Mark Robertson
 
This episode feels bizarre to me because of the way this episode was written, it feels like it came from a full on reboot of the original series but it’s not a reboot and is a continuation of it instead. I’m beginning to understand why some people in the fandom theorise that the CGI era is a whole new timeline but what we do know from both past production teams, Miller/Barlow and Brenner/McCue, is that the series is one whole timeline, their words not mine.

The reason this feels bizarre with it feeling like an episode from a reboot was how Thomas was depicted. He feels like he was a new engine on Sodor and was still learning his way around about his new home and with that the famous lion statue. I would’ve forgiven the episode if S13 was an actual reboot, but this isn’t a reboot it’s a continuation of the original series and you think Thomas would know about the statue too? Sure not every writer would have encyclopaedic knowledge of the characters but surely the writer, who had written some episodes for S12 would know it would make sense, even if Henry says the damage to the statue happened a long time ago and not all the engines would even remember it and Thomas’ character in this episode? Oh my god he was just really, really, really downright dumb. 

Was there a character bible with the production team? Did they still use Phil Ferhle’s one from 2003? Or did they bin that and hoped for the best? And I feel that the Fat Controller scolding him for ruining the statue with straw, syrup and fish was so unfair when clearly the episode says that Thomas didn’t know what the ‘special, special’ was!
 
So really it was the Fat Controller’s fault for not telling Thomas what it was and sure if he did tell him then we wouldn’t have a story, but you can easily change that if you have the Fat Controller telling Thomas he was to collect a lion and Thomas darts off excitedly thinking he was going to take an animal and there the stuff ups happens after he collected the statue. I also think the episode could’ve been about Thomas trying to impress some children who thought a statue was boring and when he collected it he told them it was a real lion and with that the kids fed it syrup, fish and straw. It could at least give the driver some intelligence instead of just being a mindless zombie whose only purpose was to be the hands for the engines. Then after the damage was done, the kids learned how the statue was famous and volunteered to clean it up in time for the mayor and apologised to Thomas for putting pressure on him with Thomas apologising for lying.
 
The episode was another bad episode and man, S13 had really gone off with a rough start.
 
Rating:
1/10
 
TICKLED PINK
Written by Allan Plenderleith
 
I know this episode is a fan favourite and I can see why because this is something train related with an engine getting an undercoat or ‘paint, paint’ as it’s called, and I don’t know why they thought of calling it that? Undercoat is not that hard to get with what was shown visually. It’s a layer of paint to prevent corrosion and other problems an engine might face before they get the final coat on. This is the same show that had words like ‘Deputation’, ‘Sagacity’ and ‘Enterprising’, words that could increase the development of a child’s vocabulary. It feels wrong to dumb down words because it stagnates the very thing and if there are words that are complicated to pronounce for a child they could always ask their parents on how its pronounced and what it means. As I said before, kids are smarter than what society gives them credit for.

The rest of the episode just feels very undercooked as all it just is James getting a new coat and is being teased about it by the other engines for no reason, the other engines were being downright mean for no reason! Imagine showing this to someone as an introduction to the show, they would hate it and say it’s not good for kids, I believe I would if I was not familiar with the show.
 
If James had been vain and arrogant about his special job of taking the Fat Controller’s granddaughter for her birthday and he was to have a special coat of paint for the occasion. Perhaps one of the engines teased him and said that he should be painted pink because he was tickled pink about his red coat, but James scoffed and dismiss the importance of the colours and says that’s it’s only good as an undercoat and the next day he was given his undercoat, but no red paint and he had to collect Bridget and her friends. James refused to go but the Fat Controller told him that she was waiting and was looking forward to her train ride and so James, reluctantly, went on his way and there you have the engines laughing at him until he refuses to go on any further but would soon feel bad and put his pride beside for the sake of the Fat Controller’s granddaughter who told James just how splendid he was in pink and it made James appreciate it more than ever and was eventually repainted into his red livery giving off the message that you should put your pride aside for the sake of others.
 
It may not be perfect and maybe some people might say that it sounds like another James gets punished episode but my god it’s much better and entertaining than the actual crap that was this episode. The actual episode was bland, predictable and just exists for the sake of existence. It had a unique premise, but it doesn’t excuse this nothing burger of an episode.
 
Rating:
2/10
 
DOUBLE TROUBLE
Written by Sharon Miller
 
This is pretty much another nothing burger episode that had some wasted potential. The idea that the Fat Controller has a brother who was jovial, fun and playful seems like an interesting contrast to the likes of the kind but stern and serious controller that we all know and love. There’s potential for an episode and I’m surprised that the Brenner/McCue era production team hadn’t thought of doing a buddy comedy type of episode with them. Perhaps the two Hatt’s have a bit of a rift with each other and must work together after getting lost somewhere and learned that all in all they are family and must look out for each other. Suddery Stationmaster did a much better story than this episode when showcasing the difference between the two, it’s called ‘Gate-Crasher!’ and you can watch it here.
 
The actual episode was basically, Thomas was too dumb to know that the Fat Controller has a brother, took him around Sodor and he caused problems until his brother was found with Bertie and that was it. It feels like nothing and is another boring, bland, forgettable episode.

Rating:
1/10
 
SLIPPY SODOR
Written by Mark Robertson
 
One thing that I find as a breath of fresh air, though this would be a rarity is that in the sequence of Thomas being fitted with different funnels at the steamworks we didn’t have any yammering from the storyteller telling us things that we already know. It feels so nice on the ears with room to breathe after each dialogue. It was probably my favourite part of the episode. However, this was another boring dumb Thomas episode where the laughter and teasing from Gordon, Henry and James could’ve worked as a montage and that’s it, like it did in ‘Thomas’ Animal Friends’ from S24 during BWBA era. We didn’t need to be told three times that Thomas didn’t like to be teased and run away, and the new funnel plot device could easily be removed and be about Thomas being excited about taking the bubble liquid and was told by those three engines to slow down. Animal Friends, during its montage didn’t need Thomas yammering away the same syllables and vowels over and over and over again. Say what you want about BWBA but it’s nowhere nears as bad as this era!
 
Nothing drastically would change, and it was only implemented because what’s the number one thing for HIT Entertainment at the time? TOYS! LOTS AND LOTS OF TOY VARIANTS OF THOMAS WITH A CRAPPY RED FUNNEL BECAUSE THE MANUFACTURES LOVE COSTCUTTING!! Seriously, some of the toys based on this episode just cheaply reskinned Thomas’ funnel, apart from Japan who actually made that weird funnel. 

Though I will give the episode credit for some of its direction like the tracking shot with the Fat Controller’s car but the whole three strike sequence’s lack of music feels so empty without driving the stakes of it and man the storyteller should really stop talking and let the visuals do the work to showcase the Fat Controller’s car going haywire. Nothing would be missed. Anyway, this was another bland episode.
 
Rating:
1/10
 
THE EARLY BIRD
Written by David Richard Fox
 
I think the opening dialogue could’ve been dedicated to Percy and the mail train and how important it was and how Percy often stays quiet when delivering the post, which would be good for setting up the events of this episode. Because what does Gordon pulling the express have to do with the subject matter as well as Thomas’ branch line, they just feel so random. Also it's weird how it was said Thomas had never pulled the mail train, but he did in the last season in the final model era episode ‘Best Friends’. I know that the people who wrote the episodes aren’t Thomas fans who have knowledge of the show but surely someone in the production team would’ve noticed an error like. Perhaps, as The Unlucky Tug put it for the latter of his thoughts of it all from his S13 retrospective, they wrote these episodes quickly and didn’t give a crap about any of the mistakes.
 
While the whole point of this episode was for Thomas to learn not to disrupt everyone’s sleep, this is highly impossible in real life since steam engines are loud machines that have no volume control anywhere. It’s a stupid idea and it doesn’t make sense. How can this episode be improved, I don’t know. How could you make any sense, I don’t know either. Another boring, dull episode that shares the repetitive three strikes formula. It feels pretty much like ‘Edward and the Mail’ only Thomas was more excited than worried about pulling it. Pretty much the worst episode of this season to me.
 
Rating:
0/10
 
PLAYTIME
Written by Sharon Miller
 
It’s ironic that Billy was planned to be in the episode ‘Splish, Splash, Splosh’ for S12, but was withheld for this season and that his debut episode ‘Don’t Be Silly Billy’ was used to test the waters of CGI, it was never released but we have storyboard images of it as proof. Yet, he was cut out of the original episode and was replaced with Charlie, likely because a new character with a difference could sell toys. But what’s ironic is that this episode feels so much like Billy’s debut episode from two seasons ago only it was Charlie thinking that Thomas is not fun, Alicia Botti sings to a small crowd and it’s Thomas who experiences the consequences of his own action, at least for this episode. Why not Charlie? Why can’t he be the one who learns the lesson that engines have to be serious about their important work but can have fun when it’s done.
 
Look, it’s all the same with these episodes because they follow the same boring old formula, and they don’t even feel like stories one bit. Charlie is the second new character to debut in the new and they are just a nothing character. The only trait he has is that he’s the ‘fun engine’ and that’s it and never experienced any of the consequences in this episode. Charlie basically exists for the sake of merchandising and that’s it. Even though Alicia Botti was alright in the episode, her part wasn’t that interesting to me. To me this was a dull episode.
 
Rating:
1/10
 
THOMAS & THE PIGS
Written by Allan Plenderleith
 
Just another Thomas is dumb episode but this time about piglets and it’s just a rehash of ‘The Lion of Sodor’ without him making a literal mess. Again, this is just another boring predictable storyline offering nothing to improve itself to be better than what is presented. A total nothing burger of an episode! I may have given some crap to AEG for its writing, and rightly so. But at least they tried to make a story entertaining even if it’s lacklustre. This isn’t me appreciating that show, that’s still the worst thing coming out from this franchise but so far this era is coming in at a close second. I used to say Magic Railroad was the worst from this franchise, but so far it’s tame compared to this mess, despite its own setbacks.
 
Rating:
0/10
 
TIME FOR A STORY
Written by Miranda Larson
 
Again, god I’m repeating this criticism like this season’s lousy overreliances on this formula, but this is another Thomas is dumb episode, and he has to put things right. There’s really nothing much else to say as I can’t find a way to improve this into a much better story. It’s a bland, boring and predictable episode just like the other episodes from this season. No wonder some people in this fandom consider this to be the worst episode of the season but then again it seems that most episodes from this season alone are all up for that title when really it should be the goddam opposite!
 
Rating:
0/10
 
PERCY’S PARCEL
Written by Robin Charteris
 
It’s nice that we don’t have Thomas in the lead role this time but if you replace Percy with him it won’t make that much difference. But other than that it was nice to see Mavis being utilised here and I do like her mature character with her soothing Percy about not getting a special but that was pretty much the stand out for me as the whole story is just the same as every other episode. Once again, boring, bland and predictable with nothing to improve to make it any better.
 
Rating:
1/10
 
TOBY’S NEW WHISTLE
Written by Louise Kramskoy
 
Honestly, the writers not knowing Toby having a steam whistle in S4 can be seen as a massive oversight. It was very obscure, and it was only used once and never again and that is that. It was only done as a requirement to the plot to move the bull and proving his own experience with cattle to Daisy who’d badmouthed his cowcatchers from earlier. Now yes, Toby’s actual basis was implemented with steam whistles but even in the Railway Series, Toby’s whistle was never that much of an important feature to him anyway for any story apart from ‘Bullseyes'.

But finally we have a story that has more potential than what was given to us. This is another story where if you can change the character the story will stay the same and with that you could change it up to an engine who was excited about getting a new steam whistle that is loud and booming, perhaps Percy or Emily who were teased earlier by some kids over their old whistle which made them very sensitive. They were also pleased with their new whistle that they’d scared a few people and passing engines who had enjoyed the sound of their old whistle and both of them felt bad and thought their new one was terrible until they learned just how useful it is while still appreciating their old whistle. It’s not a buddy plot, I was picturing just one or the other.
 
It's like ‘Percy’s New Whistle’ from S8 only that the whistle is actually new. Same story, yes but hey it’s better than this crap. Or if you want to keep the original plot of the episode but add in some changes, perhaps you could make it about James who was proud of his old whistle and tries to find ways of not using it until he learns its usefulness.
 
Toby just seems like an odd choice to lead this episode, and I know that this would be his persona throughout the CG era of the original show. But to be honest, the Brenner/McCue era Toby has its ups and down but it’s much better than the one-note Toby who has the personality of Eeyore from ‘Winnie the Pooh’ without the nuance in this era of the original show. I do agree with The Unlucky Tug from his retrospective video of this season. This episode really makes the characters stupid, let all the other episodes where they have no awareness of their surroundings until the plot requires them too. I say for Thomas when he was coming towards the cows why not have him dealing with the trucks who were being troublesome? At least he would have a distraction before knowing the cows were on the line, at least that would make complete sense instead of him just smiling and chuffing along mindlessly like the idiot that he was in this season. Maybe for Gordon he could’ve struck up a conversation with either James or Henry while puffing down the track, both of these at least could make some sense instead of them being idiots.
 
While the lesson was nice, the story had more potential to be better than what was given to us.
 
Rating:
1/10
 
A BLOOMING MESS
Written by Miranda Larson
 
This title perfectly sums up this season so far! But only eight more of these episodes to go. Thank god there are 20 episodes instead of 52 like AEG’s first two seasons. But anyway, I will say this episode was less grating to get through as the three strikes skimmed through with Emily saying hello to James and Toby as the first two and Mavis was the last one. But I think this is another episode that had potential with Emily’s bossy side where you can have her looking after the quarry while Mavis was away at the works. Emily was bossing the engines around, perhaps to show Mavis that she can look after the quarry well on her own and impress her, and it created a terrible mess around the quarry, like ‘Emily Knows Best’ from S9, same story but much better than this.
 
The whole episode that we got is pretty much the same as any other episode where if you replace Emily with any other character you get the same results beat by beat. Like I can see Percy working in this role or Henry or even Edward with the generic, boring goody-good characterisation. This one was tame, though Emily's lack of self-awareness was still grating with her leaving the flowers near the hopper and all without knowing that there could be other engines nearby.
 
It's a tame episode but with a lot to be desired like some of the other episodes. Fun fact, this is the highest rated episode so far!
 
Rating:
3.5/10
 
THOMAS AND THE RUNAWAY KITE
Written by Louise Kramskoy
 
I think this episode should’ve gone to Charlie to show that he’s more than the one-note jokester, fun engine character. Perhaps you can make them to prove that they are the fastest engine on Sodor and maybe team up with Gordon, I mean it makes sense, and I think Gordon would be honoured by pulling a wagon that carries a trophy, you could have him say that he’s as fast as a kite. You might say that Thomas would fit the bill, but Thomas had so many episodes this season that having Charlie to be the main character is more of a fresh choice that would expand more of their character. Sure it had been done before, at least to my knowledge, where a character proves themselves.
 
I know Thomas is the most important character of the show at this point and that he must have a leading role in almost every episode but come on give us something different! Thomas can at least have a supporting role and we’ve seen that in past episodes of this season, it can still work regardless!
 
One other thing I find grating in this episode is that they don’t mention the Fat Controller’s grandchildren by name only by title and boy they made it such a mouthful, ‘I’ve lost the Fat Controller’s grandchildren’s kite!’ is it really that hard to just call them Stephen and Bridget? You can place Hatt at the end of their names and people would still know who you’re referring to, especially if they have seen past episodes prior to this season. ‘I’ve lost Stephen and Bridget’s kite’ flows much better and is less clunky. It’s a nitpick but man it was annoying.

The whole point of the episode is for Thomas to learn that he is not the fastest engine on Sodor, but it never really came off as him trying to prove that he is, no one was putting him down that he isn’t or anything. He never came across as arrogant or stuck up. All he just said is that he was the fastest engine and that’s it. If you have changed it up to the scenario that I had written earlier it would at least be clear. It's a typical S13 script that had potential but didn’t live up to it. Like it’s fine, it wasn’t too awful, but it was just very boring and forgettable.

Rating:
2.5/10
 
STEAMY SODOR
Written by Sharon Miller
 
And we’re back to another episode of Thomas being dumb! It’s just another three strikes you’re out storyline with repetitive dialogue and that’s it. Plus it’s another episode where if you replace Thomas with another character, nothing will change beat by beat. You can have James take Thomas’ place and it would still be the same and to be honest an episode like this would be suited for him with his arrogance and prideful character. It might be another James is a jerk storyline that had been overdone but I would take that any day over another Thomas is dumb storyline. To make it more engaging, why not have it focused on Kevin hoping he would take over the job for Victor but was upset that someone with no experience would do the job instead.

The reason Kevin wasn’t put in charge is because of his constant crashing around the steamworks and by the end of all the chaos, Kevin was the one who put things right showing that despite his shortcomings, he knows the steamworks just as much as Victor. It would’ve been an interesting storyline than this one, what a shame for the amount of missed opportunities this season had if they had thought outside the box for once.

All in all this was a pretty boring, drabby episode. There was some subtle humour like Spencer’s coal-stache and there was some of that stuff in other episodes too, but it didn’t leave that much of an impression on me, not that it’s bad or anything, it just doesn’t really excuse the overall product.

Rating:
1/10
 
SPLISH, SPLASH, SPLOSH
Written by Sharon Miller
 
As I said earlier, this was a planned S12 episode but was held back for this season, don’t know what the reason was behind that decision but despite that this was just another Thomas is dumb episode, ignoring all the previous lessons that he had done in this season. I will say though the three strikes formula does actually work here for the build up towards the Fat Controller and Alicia Botti getting soaked but despite that I think this could’ve been a Charlie focused episode and maybe you can finally have him being told off for his silliness instead of getting away with it. It’s still not a great episode and if it were a scrapped, lost episode I wouldn’t lose much sleep over it. There really isn’t much to say on what to improve this episode but one other nitpick I will point out is the inconsistency with realism where Thomas’ firebox wasn’t soaked by the puddles but after his big splash, somehow it did. It feels like an ‘All Engines Go!’ episode where realism is one useful for plot reason and isn’t useful for the rest of the story.
 
Rating:
1/10
 
THE BIGGEST PRESENT OF ALL
Written by Sharon Miller
 
Like The Unlucky Tug, I too think they should’ve held Hiro back for a few seasons to give us time to miss him instead of just bringing him back after his farewell at the end of ‘Hero of the Rails’ which really undermined it all. Anyway, this was another so-so episode sharing the same template, but it wasn’t the worst that I’ve seen, seriously a barn for Hiro? It was nice to see Thomas trying to find a present for Hiro, despite him being dumb yet again. Thomas’ friendship with Hiro was really nice like a young kid and his grandparent type of relationship and I do like the ending where Hiro explained to Thomas that the biggest present of all is all the friends Hiro had made since being found and restored on Sodor. It was a sweet ending and a nice episode, despite its setbacks. Probably the best episode of the 13th season, and that is saying something!
 
Rating:
5.5/10
 
SNOW TRACKS
Written by Alan Hescott
 
The Fat Controller tells Gordon to take the long way around because the snow is slippery. How is that logical and what difference does it make? It would be covered by snow too! Sure it was done so Gordon would prevent it at first until he realised his mistake and did take it as instructed. But hills or not, you could easily make it about Gordon going too fast as he ploughs deep drifts off the tracks and not realising he was causing trouble to the other engines that were coming the opposite way because he was too proud and boastful about himself to notice. 

How would the giant snowball work at the climax, well you can have Gordon pushing the thick snow on a flat surface and after the track was cleared, he would give it a shove until it hit Thomas in a siding. The show at this point in time had given up on all grounded logic and lacked any amount of sense. It’s the same story if you change it to that and that’s it and the lesson after the third strike you can have Gordon putting things right by slowing down and not causing any trouble to the other engines at all. I will admit, it is nice to see Gordon learning from his mistakes and putting things right, even if he is arrogant and boastful and especially towards Thomas. It feels like an extension of their alliance after the events of ‘Down the Mine’ “You help me, and I’ll help you.”

I am surprised Andrew Brenner, Ian McCue or anyone from the Brenner/McCue era production team hadn’t done a story like that between S17-24 and I believe it might’ve been better. The dynamic between them in this episode was probably the only saving grace, it was nice. I know some people in the fandom in this day and age are now disparaging the Brenner/McCue era when it comes to Gordon’s character and I will admit he was mostly seen as arrogant and boastful but he too had shown some shortcomings of his behaviour in some episodes and learns his lesson, even if he was too proud to admit it, let’s face it it’s more realistic since narcissists barely learn anything at all and perhaps the Brenner/McCue era Gordon would be seen more as a cautionary character, teaching kids not to behave like him. Sure those lessons are then forgotten about in the next episode from that era, but these episodes had done the same too.

While Gordon and Thomas’ dynamic come off as a highlight for me, the episode was another so-so with the same standard three strike formula and even if you change it up, it will still have the same outcome.

Rating:
4/10
 
HENRY’S GOOD DEEDS
Written by Alan Hescott
 
It’s nice that there was some variety with the characters but if you replace Henry with either Percy, James or Emily whoever you will get the same episode beat by beat and yes I know me saying that over and over and over again is pretty tiring. I remember saying back in 2015 that this episode was a good choice for the ‘1st Class Stories’ DVD but now I see it as another bland, boring, forgettable, predictable episode, you know like the rest of S13 and as I said earlier, you could have any character taking the lead role and it’s still the same episode. 

Perhaps it would change up a little bit with James being arrogant and desperate to make a good deed given his history of arrogance. I know Tug said in his retrospective video that Henry’s nature loving side had come back for this episode, but I did not see much of it. It was never really a nature episode apart from the bird. 

Plus it’s a pretty big contradiction to have the Sodor warbler being scared of Henry’s whistle and yet not scared of him by the noise nor even by the passengers cheering but hey it’s for plot reasons. This was a meh episode to me.
 
Rating:
3/10
 
BUZZY BEES
Written by Sharon Miller
 
All together now, ‘another Thomas is dumb episode!’ at least this is the last one of this season! There’s really not much to say as it’s just your typical S13 story where Thomas just learns the same lesson as every other episode with no character development, no self-awareness of his own actions and such bland characterisation where the same plot can be fitted with any other engine. You could put Percy into the mix and it’s still the same episode. Plus why would Thomas not know what a bee hive is as if this episode was also made as if they’d rebooted the show? Hell reboot or not, Thomas would at least know what bee hives are, such an unnecessary scene. Do they think kids have no idea what bee hives are? Speaking of that scene, as much as I love Hiro, his role could’ve been easily replaced by Edward with the wise old man role. Basically any change can be done, and you still have the same episode. I don’t know how you can improve it to make it any better. This is just another poorly written episode.
 
Rating:
1/10
 
HIRO HELPS OUT
Written by Sharon Miller
 
This is ‘The Green Controller’ but with the engines’ intelligence hitting a massive rock bottom. Why the hell do the engines have jobs but having no idea where to go and have to ask the Fat Controller on where to take them? Surely they would’ve gotten instructions from the workmen via the man in the top hat? What did the engines listen to the instructions and forget about it one millisecond later? At least in the former, the other engines at least have some brains to question Percy’s orders and that was written by the same writer as well. In the past she was treated harshly by the Thomas fandom and likely because none of us knew the production side of things any better. I cannot blame her solely for these creative decisions in this season and very likely the next three seasons after this and I believe there would’ve been some executive meddling involved and if that was the case then had these executives ever met a child? Because with the condescending plotline, repetitiveness and very simple and very clunky dialogue do they think a kid is stupid?

I digress, while I understand Hiro was a new character for this season and has to have an episode to himself I feel this could be given to Edward and, yes will be saying this again, you will get the same episode beat by beat. Sure many people will say that Edward would be out of character, but do you think the executives, or the writing staff would care about that? Of course not and we had ‘Edward Strikes Out’ for god sake!

This story was another badly written, easily forgettable and bland storyline, yada, yada, yada, I think you all get the picture by now and with this being the season finale what a dismal way to go out on.
 
Rating:
0/10
 
OVERALL
A cartoon train with a face on it

AI-generated content may be incorrect.
 
Wow just wow! If I were to sum up this season with a single clip, it would be this! This was a very rough start for a new era of Thomas. The characterisation of the engines just feel indistinguishable and feel if they had been lobotomised to have any personality whatsoever so that they could serve in any story with the same outcome and the same lesson. They’re all so boring, lacked any sort of nuance and had an incredible loss of potential to actually make the stories better even if the characters weren’t like their original selves from the very early seasons of the show.

 
I was watching the UK dub of the season and man I hate how robotic they all sound. The voice actors are talented people but because they have to mime the acting of the US dub, it felt like all the life was sucked out of them and it’d gotten really grating as time went on. Ben Small is one who really sticks out with me because at some point in the season we went from high-pitched squeaky Thomas in the early part and then later he toned down his voice which I will say was better in my opinion because the squeaky voice can get annoying at times, no disrespect towards Ben Small here. I didn’t watch the US dub for comparison and to be honest I don’t want to sit through this crap again and that will be the case for the next three seasons after this. Speaking of the UK dub, Michael Angelis was pretty much trying but just couldn’t reach the same energy or enthusiasm that he had the last few seasons and some of the energy that he was trying to pull really felt tacked on in some parts. This is by no means of any disrespect towards the late narrator, but it just shows.
 
 
The episodes from this era didn’t feel like stories at all; they just felt mechanical with no character development nor any complexities or substances. Speaking of character complexity, I remember people were complaining about Thomas’ character in ‘Journey Beyond Sodor’ saying that he acts like a brat and why are we rooting for him but man at least he’d learned his lesson, and we don’t see him acting like that again in the episodes from S21 and speaking of his character, I adore how the Brenner/McCue era gave Thomas some complexity. The episode ‘Unscheduled Stops’ comes to mind where Thomas was shown dropping off some passengers in between stations while Bertie was away being repaired and while Thomas had good intentions and thought nothing could go wrong he would later realise his mistake with the other passengers complaining about being late and all.
 
 
He knew the consequences of his own action and tried to make things right but cannot leave behind the passengers who were waiting in between spots. In this season, Thomas had none of that and even after he’d learned his lesson we would end up with another episode of him doing the same thing but within a different situation, in one ear out the other. Thomas in JBS was complex and while that special has its own setbacks as well, I would rather be rooting for Thomas more than this lobotomy on wheels. Why should I be rooting for him as a character when he can’t learn the same lesson over and over and over and over and over and over and over again? Surely if parents want kids to have a positive role model in mind then the S13-16 version of Thomas is certainly not the type of character to look up to.
 
 
Some people over the years had always complained about the older version of Thomas being too mean or angry with each other because oh sure kids don’t have those types of traits that may’ve learned from their parents or siblings at home or friends at school and yet no one complained, at least to my knowledge, how this sugar coated version of Thomas is so idiotic and barely learns the same lesson.

A cartoon of a train

AI-generated content may be incorrect.
 
When rewatching this season, I couldn’t help but think of ‘All Engines Go!’ because there are some similarities that this season had with that show and the latter wouldn’t have come out until over a decade later. The similarities I can point would be the bland characterisation, the thin storylines that was padded out with a three strike formula repeating the same situation over and over again, the restricted cast, recycled storylines and situations and the ‘cargo of the day’ stuff, even with things like boxes, presents, beehives or whatever on conflat wagons. But despite that AEG at least, to an extent had some good episodes, some! There is still some badness from that show, and I will say it’s on par with this era when it comes to the title of the worst thing that came from this franchise.
 
A cartoon of a person in a hat

AI-generated content may be incorrect.
 
While I understand that the storyteller is an important part of Thomas’ DNA, man how I hate the constant usage of them, and I believe they should’ve cut down their lines to allow the animation to express the character’s emotions instead of the two Michael’s telling us on how the characters are feeling. It might’ve worked in the model era due to its limitations, but this is CGI! HIT Entertainment wanted the show to be more expressive but they didn’t think of dialling back the storyteller? This is one of things that made me appreciate the Brenner/McCue era of the show because overtime with each season, the storyteller had been decreased but not too much and is only there when needed and let the animation do all the talking. Like you didn’t see the storyteller telling the viewer that the Fat Controller was running away from a bull in ‘The Beast of Sodor’ it showed us that.

 
The other problem that this season had faced was its direction, there was at least one good tracking shot of the Fat Controller’s car in ‘Slippy Sodor’ but that was it because the rest of the season showcased repeated angles in the episodes. The model series did the same thing, but this was the introduction of Thomas in CGI, and you think Nitrogen Studios might want to showcase the idea to many sceptics who’d doubted this venture but instead try to replicate what the model era had done. The still shots are just dull and unengaging, and this is why I’m glad Andrew Brenner and Ian McCue had taken the helm during their reign of Thomas. As each season progressed we saw more camera tricks and angles that would be impossible in the model era where it had restricted spacing in the studio. They had taken the advantage of what CGI can do. I’m still at awe of the camera position in ‘Lost Property’ of S19 when it was pointed upwards to Thomas where we see his undercarriage, the time forward skip jump in both ‘The Adventure Begins’ when Thomas was shunting throughout the day and in ‘Thomas and the Babysitter’ where we see people zipping by while Thomas was getting more and more exhausted and the camera going 360 degrees in ‘Salty All at Sea’. They were all fantastic and it’s a shame it was at the time when people were already used to the show being a full CG production.
 
A cartoon of a train and a crane

AI-generated content may be incorrect.
 
Nitrogen Studios could’ve done it at the time but decided to play it safe and be like the model series itself. Maybe it was done to save time during production, but Jam Filled and Arc would’ve had the same schedule and yet still have done better direction than Nitrogen had ever done. Sure Nitrogen may’ve had some good textures and depth within its work but the repeated camera angles and all in each of the episodes gives off a bit of cheapness to it in my opinion. If this was my first introduction to CGI Thomas without seeing ‘Hero of the Rails’ I would’ve been very disappointed by it all and wouldn’t have been sold on the concept. It’s smart of HIT Entertainment to have the former come out first and to let the special showcase the potential that CGI Thomas can do.
 
A blue and gold object with a clock

AI-generated content may be incorrect.
 
Speaking of Nitrogen, the animation doesn’t really hold well in my opinion. The characters look like they were either made out of plastic and the early lighting didn’t really add much depth to make the settings and characters look any better, some shots even feel like a cutscene for a PS2 game, even in HD, though it is a shame that the best accessible way to view them for free is someone’s DVD rips of the season when it was released in the UK around 2012. For HD you have to make sure they are still up for download, depending on location, and some countries might just have the standard definition, or you could find it on whoever is streaming it.
 
 
Nitrogen didn’t do a bad job at replicating the character to what they were in the past and still kept the characters uniquely Thomas though there toyish look do stick out from the detailed look of Hiro and Charlie and all and I never liked the chunky steam when the engines were puffing, especially when the camera looks towards them overhead. There was just too much of it and they should’ve toned it down.

A cartoon of a train

AI-generated content may be incorrect.

If you haven’t seen S13 as a whole I recommend skipping it and only watch the two episodes containing Hiro as that was the only status quo change this season had done. Hiro’s a fine character and probably the best thing that came out from this season along with Victor and Kevin with their doctor and assistant dynamic. There had been some good moments here and there like Gordon’s dynamic with Thomas in ‘Snow Tracks’ and Thomas’ dynamic with Hiro like a kid and a grandfather, they were nice little gems but sadly the majority of it all was a stinkfest.


The overall rating I’d given to this season is so far the lowest that I’d given to any season of the show within the whole franchise and that includes ‘All Engines Go!’ Well at least that show has some advantage despite being on par. With that done, now I’ll be giving my verdict on ‘Hero of the Rails’ soon. I know the special came out before S13 had aired but I like being consistent by reviewing the special after sitting through a whole season.
 
Overall Rating:
30.5/120