Sunday, 22 November 2026

Movie Re-Review: Hero of the Rails (2009)

Like every other season that has a special alongside, here is my take on ‘Hero of the Rails’ and I hadn’t seen this movie since I last reviewed it in 2014, how time flies! The last time that I’d reviewed this movie was in anticipation for ‘Tale of the Brave’ when it was being released and oh how I miss that era of the show when it was at its finest. There’s really not much else to say as I’d already explained the history about the show’s transformation into CGI in my recent series 13 review so I think we should get on with the show. But first:

THESE ARE MY OPINIONS AND ARE NOT INFLUENCED FROM THE THOMAS & FRIENDS FANDOM

HERO OF THE RAILS
Written by
Sharon Miller

Directed by
Greg Tiernan

Produced by
Nicole Stinn

Plot
Follow Thomas as he discovers Hiro, an abandoned engine from a faraway land. Fearing that Hiro will be scrapped, Thomas enlists the help of many friends, but mishaps, mistakes and one boastful engine could foil their rescue plans.


Release Date
8/09/09 - US
1/10/09 - AUS
12/10/09 - UK


Distributed by
HIT Entertainment (US/AU/UK)
Lionsgate (US)
ABC (AUS)


MY VIEWS


The special opens up without the storyteller yammering away any pointless unnecessary stuff about the engines puffing and chuffing, being busy or whatever. We just know that it’s summer, birds are singing and flowers and blossoming and then bam we got onto one of the establishing plot points of the movie with Spencer coming to the Island of Sodor to help build the Duke and Duchess’ summerhouse. I also like how with this being the introduction to the new CG era of Thomas we’re given a spotlight to all of the main eight characters and their individual voices as of course this was one of the biggest changes in the show’s history as in previous seasons it was all done by a single storyteller harking back to the days of Ringo Starr in 1984.


I also really like how they were showing what can be done with CGI Thomas like with Spencer going so fast that he was a blur and with that dirt and stones can fly off the engines which adds more detail compared to what they can do in the model era of the show as well as the dynamic camera angles and tracking shots as well as showing Toby being uncoupled from Henrietta in just one shot. The same can be said with the opening establishing shot with flowers in the foreground, hills in the distance and birds swooping by. The camera lowered down looking towards the engines making them look huge and life-size. This is by no means disrespecting what the model makers had achieved over their last 25 years not by a long shot. The model era still remains something so dear to me and even in 2026 I’m still amazed on what they could pull off with such limitations.


The next day, Thomas was at the docks and after being called a toy by Spencer and with his friends defending him, Spencer challenged Thomas to a race the next day as a test of strength. As the two make their way out of the yard we get some of the typical rhyming dialogue, but I think it was sprinkled here and there but it would become a massive problem later on in the early CGI era’s run. But despite that Nitrogen went all out with this sequence with the camera work, especially the tracking shots which is something that can’t be done with models, not at the speed Thomas was going at, and I think if it were done with models it would just be the camera attaching to Thomas with his shocked face and then cut to him racing down the line as a still shot.


With Spencer back on Sodor yet again, we get a montage of clips of him being rude to the other engines which is pretty much the same as the opening scene with only some engines showcasing their voices but while it may look like something to pad out the run time, it was useful to showcase Spencer’s character progression from being the smug, narcissistic prick of an engine to be this downright maniacal engine who wanted a fellow steam engine scrapped.


Though I think Thomas bashing into the trucks was kind of pointless as they didn't serve anything, and it didn’t really do enough damage on him. You could have a shot of Thomas’ crew trying to find other ways to make him stop like reducing steam or shutting off his regulator which could make sense to him stopping in the woods and it would still serve the moment when Thomas found Hiro. Speaking of the wood, I love how everything was animated from the immense detail of the various trees surrounding him, the lighting within the forest all of it, it was stellar! A crying shame that they never went full on with that during S13!


After the race and the runaway, Thomas heard a voice and it was from Hiro an engine who was one of the first steam engines who had come to the Island of Sodor many years ago from Japan, creating a spanner in the works for the show’s own lore. The reason he was put into an old siding is because he broke down sometime after he arrived on Sodor and there weren’t any parts for him, but the parts had never come. I really don’t see the reason to not name drop Japan when we had clear, obvious signs that he came from there given the 2D art flashback in the style of traditional woodblock painting, hell they’d even referenced ‘The Great Wave off Kanagawa’ one of, if not, the most famous art piece from Japan, when Hiro was being shipped to Sodor.


I understand Sodor because ever since Britt Allcroft was in charge, she wanted Thomas’ home to be an island that could be anywhere, but I believe everyone knew that Thomas was from the UK despite their own dubs. Sure not many Japanese families knew that Thomas had come from there but in ‘Thomas & Gordon’ they said that Sodor was part of the UK, prior to ‘The Great Race’ where Sodor is now called its own country. America knew since they had Ringo Starr as the storyteller for ‘Shining Time Station’ and even when I was a kid I knew Thomas was not Australian. I’m glad that the whole thing had been scrapped by Brenner and his team during their time on the show. After Hiro’s backstory, a rarity in this era of the show considering that most newbies at the time just showed up because of plot reasons to sell toys, which makes Hiro such an interesting character with a goal in mind of being restored back into steam.


However, it has to be done in secret because Hiro feared that because he was too old he’s no longer reparable and was worthy for scrap. Sure it’s easy to say, ‘but the Fat Controller doesn’t scrap steam engines!!’ which is true, at least in the TV series, the Railway Series that’s a different story, but Hiro doesn’t know that since he had been stored away in the siding for such a long time. But it does seem strange that Thomas just accepted Hiro’s reason despite knowing the Fat Controller well.


I remember someone found some hidden audio files of the special’s tie-in video game and in them Stanley was involved with the discovery of Hiro and I think, if that was the case, it would make some sense, at least for Stanley since this special came out one year after ‘The Great Discovery’ and that he was new to island and so he wouldn’t know much about the Fat Controller and so him thinking Hiro might be scrapped seems to work for him being a newbie and all plus I think a Stanley/Spencer dynamic would be interesting, both are strong engines in their own way but Spencer would end up being the stronger one out of the two when it comes to pulling trucks and hearing Spencer saying that Hiro should be scrapped by the Fat Controller might ring further fears of that possibility.


It would give a nice message to kids, and for some in this fandom, about not listening to false rumours about someone and maybe go and talk to them instead of keeping secrets or instantly believing in BS, again some people in the fandom should take note of it, because you’re only going to make things worse. But Thomas is the lead instead because he’s the title character, although you could have him as a support character for Stanley. I think it could make for an interesting character arc and Stanley was hardly used since the aftermath of TGD. I believe he was planned during early development because the developers making the game would need a script to try and adapt, especially when it comes to a tie-in product of a movie.


Anyway back to the film, Thomas was later sent to the steamworks to get his brakes fixed and here we’re introduced to Victor and Kevin, two of the three newbies of the special after he was fixed, Thomas found an old piston cylinder and soon got to work on his branch line and after that he returned to the steamworks and asked Victor if he could take it, he didn’t say it was for Hiro because he feared other engines might overhear him and word could spread all the way to the Fat Controller.


As he puffed along the line, Spencer was behind him and Thomas was worried that he might be questioning him about him taking the old cylinder, pretty much in the most typical Miller/Barlow era way of writing wouldn’t Spencer have seen Thomas anyway in the distance and questioned it because it was convenient? I don’t know but also I wish the scene of Spencer looking around thinking he saw Thomas had no narration because I think the scene could be a little tense without it and the music and it speaks more visually. This special would foreshadow the immense problem of the storyteller overexplaining everything when the visuals can do all of the work in the 13th season and so on.


After Thomas delivered the old cylinder he soon discovered that the Duke and Duchess’ summerhouse was close by and that Spencer would be there everyday and with that Thomas had to be careful because if Spencer finds out Hiro would surely be scrapped by the Fat Controller, again Stanley would’ve been a better choice as main character given that he’s still new to the Island of Sodor.


The next day, Thomas was having a very busy day, but he wanted to be with Hiro and soon Percy arrived and wondered why he looked sad and then Thomas told him about Hiro and promised Percy to meet him and asked him for his help by taking his load of farm machinery to Farmer McColl while he goes to Hiro. But Percy was pulling mail vans and Thomas told him to place them in the siding for safety. It’s interesting how Keith Wickham was trying to find his footing with Percy in the early days of the CGI era, his voice sounds a bit deep compared to how he voiced Percy much later during his run until 2015. It’s amazing to think that he was only Percy’s voice for six years!


So after Percy dropped off his mail vans in a siding, Thomas puffed back towards Hiro’s hiding place where Spencer spotted him and was starting to get suspicious since he was a long way from his branch line. Although, I don’t see why Spencer would get suspicious since the engines aren’t always allocated on branch lines or main lines for a long time at this point. After Thomas met with Hiro and Thomas’ crew placed in his piston, Thomas set off again and found Percy who had broken a valve. Spencer, still suspicious of Thomas, followed up from behind and told Percy that a stronger engine should’ve pulled his load. I honestly think this is where Spencer should have gone a bit extreme by saying the Fat Controller should scrap really useless engines to at least build up his villainous status.


Thomas took Percy to the steamworks and after seeing some old parts that Kevin had dropped, he told Victor about Hiro and offered Thomas whatever part he put into the corner he would take to Hiro. Later that night, Thomas was at the sheds with a very angry looking Fat Controller telling him about Percy’s missing vans. When he said ‘order’ I felt Keith Wickham’s voice was a bit flat compared to Kerry Shale in the US. Shale’s voice, from my memory, felt very authoritative and booming whereas Keith sounded stern. I understand the voice actors were finding their feet and they would eventually improve themselves in the years to come.


And here is where Thomas told the other engines about Hiro and the next day, Thomas went back to work hauling and shunting trucks while Spencer watched his every move as Gordon puffed overheard on a bridge with old engine parts for Hiro. The two engines smiled as Gordon puffed on his way, again this scene would be better without the narration. After that Gordon was done and Thomas went to the steamworks to meet up with Percy when the Fat Controller arrived still cross that the mail vans haven’t been found and ordered them to look for them tomorrow. I mean he’s a bit ungrateful given that the scene implied that Percy had been at the works all day.


After that Victor told Thomas to cheer Percy up and Thomas took him to see Hiro. The three engines chat as Hiro mentioned that he missed his friends back in his homeland and told them about Gordon and how his smile changes his whole face. As Thomas and Percy puffed their way home, Spencer lingered behind and started to snoop.


This is where the movie's pacing gets into annoying territory for me with its constant backwards and forwards as Thomas and Percy were looking for the missing mail vans and Spencer snooping while either the engines were delivering engine parts or distracting Spencer from his snooping but Spencer getting slate dust in his funnel did bare some importance so that Thomas and Percy can visit Hiro with the need of Spencer’s eagle eyes prying upon them. At the Steamworks, Kevin was dropping parts in order for Spencer to close his eyes so that Thomas could sneak away with engine parts, I mean surely Spencer would’ve heard him moving away along with the wagon since it was right in front of him? I don’t think it will make any difference if you just have Victor pull the wagon out for Thomas by saying they were to be thrown away, that could at least make some sense to trick Spencer.


Thomas went to Hiro who was missing his old friends back at home and to cheer him up, he told Hiro that Percy was to go across the island to get the final part for him. Back at the sheds, the Fat Controller was wondering what was going on with Thomas neglecting his work and all and despite promising to do those tomorrow, the other engines all agreed to take it in turns to guard Hiro, wow great lesson for kids about neglecting your other responsibilities, kind of reminds me of ‘All Engines Go!’ and some of its questionable morals for the convenience of plot.


The next day, Spencer was repaired and went off snooping to see what Thomas was up too and as he neared Hiro’s hiding place he found Percy’s mail vans but was stopped by Thomas, James and Toby and was in trouble by the Fat Controller. That afternoon, Hiro was in steam for the first time in years and all he needed was his water injector. One thing that I’d noticed in this scene was Ben Small started to give Thomas his high pitched kiddy voice that would be prominent for a bit in S13. It’s such a distraction how Thomas’ voice in the UK dub was at first nicely balanced between a high pitch voice but lowered down to not make it too annoying and then for some reason he’d changed it to sound like someone swallowed air out from a party balloon. I don’t know if this was a directional thing or a personal choice, but it sounds really annoying.


While everything was all fine and dandy, the two engines heard Spencer’s whistle in the distance, honestly the scene with Spencer finding the mail vans and being cornered by the three engines earlier in the special should’ve been least be cut and instead have it to build up the scene when Spencer rolled alongside Thomas and Hiro when they were running away from him and then get scolded at by the Fat Controller at Maithwaite, the scene that we had earlier was pretty much the same thing.


To replace the scene involving Toby, James and Thomas cornering Spencer and hin getting scolded at by the Fat Controller at Knapford, I think it should've been replaced with Percy picking up the water injector and saw Spencer snooping around and knowing there'll trouble, he raced away to Hiro’s hiding place. But Spencer saw him and followed behind, then we see Thomas chatting with Hiro until Percy came to the hideout and told them about Spencer and then they heard his whistle in distance. As he found Percy's mail vans as Thomas, Hiro and Percy start to runaway from him. It would at least add more urgency.


Maybe in one shot leading to the chase scene we see them crossing over the fenland bridge and have it start to crack once Spencer passed by, which would create build up for the climax of the special. So as Thomas and Hiro raced down the track, Spencer caught up with them and the chase was on with Hiro breaking apart. This is another example of Nitrogen going all out to show the world what CGI can do for Thomas with the amazing tracking shots and 360 degrees camera swoops creating all of this urgency in the film, Nitrogen can do this stuff and barely did it for the season following this. What a waste. I also feel this scene would also work without the storyteller yammering away on what we can see.


While I understand that people liked Spencer being the villain in all this, I feel this role could’ve been done with Diesel or maybe you can bring in a bigger diesel to the mix if you want to retain the things that Spencer was used for like the race between him and Thomas earlier in the special. HIT still had plenty of models in storage from the past 2 and a half decades at the time. 


They could’ve had D261 filling in the role based on either reference pictures or sending the actual model to Nitrogen with the others for production; that did happen and there are photographs on the studio’s wiki page for all to see. D261 could’ve easily filled in Spencer’s role, or maybe a diesel that shares the same shape as him, and nothing different would happen, apart from the construction of the Boxford’s summerhouse but you might replace it with an entirely different project like maybe a museum or something.


My point is it’s unique that Spencer was given the villainous role, but it just wasn’t unique enough in my opinion to make it for Spencer. Because the old steam engine should be scrapped is a pretty overdone trope in the show and Spencer doesn’t make it anymore unique. Since Hiro was deemed as famous in this special, for some reason, why not have Hiro be this legendary engine who had broken records on Sodor or, if you want to respect his basis’ actual history, the strongest engine on Sodor. He doesn’t have to have the title ‘Master of the Railway’, that’s just some vague crap to make him more mysterious, kind of like Ash Ketchum’s goal in ‘Pokémon’ to be a ‘Pokémon Master’ until we got our reason in his final episode as main character.


One day, Hiro broke down and was forgotten when he was abandoned in a siding and years later, Spencer became the strongest engine with him pulling building materials for the summer house project, this is if you preserve what was done in the final cut. Perhaps Spencer had heard about Hiro and heard a rumour that the reason he’d disappeared is because he broke down, which would later turn out to be true. 


When Hiro was found by Thomas or Stanley, if you want to be adventurous, perhaps for Stanley you could have him being ticked off by Spencer for calling him weak since he too is a strong engine, same as Thomas in the final cut but it would make sense for it to be Stanley since it was said in TGD special that he was stronger than Thomas and you could have his strength to be challenged and perhaps you could have Spencer teasing him saying that the Fat Controller should scrap weak little engines, which would worry Stanley since he’s still new to Sodor and doesn’t know the Fat Controller very well.


Stanley could still keep Hiro a secret from Spencer, and the other engines until he told them, until he, Spencer, caught wind from one of the other engines and he tries to see it for himself which could result in him being found and chasing after him with his parts falling off and all. It's not a perfect summary of what I can do to improve this but to me this sounds miles better than what we got. What we got is the same problem that S13 had suffered with, if you replace an engine with another like Percy with Thomas in ‘Percy’s Parcel’ or Henry with either James, Emily or Edward in ‘Henry’s Good Deeds’, you’re just getting the same outcome. But I think with Stanley at the helm it might give out the message that although Stanley isn't strong in strength, he is strong-minded.


Now with that rambling out of the way, back to the special. Thomas felt terrible and then Gordon came past and challenged Spencer to a race to Maithwaite station as Thomas found a small siding for Hiro to hide in while Hiro laments his downfall. Meanwhile, Gordon and Spencer arrived at the station with the big blue engine winning the race. Then outstepped from Gordon’s coaches were the Duke and Duchess of Boxford who had scolded Spencer for neglecting his job and with that his pride had fallen and was almost going to be sent back to the mainland until Thomas offered to help build the summerhouse.


Everyone was now worried for Hiro and Thomas decided to tell the Fat Controller about Hiro and need his help repairing him for good. But first, Thomas was to help work on the summer house to prove to the Fat Controller that he is really useful, I guess that was the goal Thomas was going for in the whole special since he had been neglecting his duties, but it didn’t feel like a strong motivation. Thomas worked hard for the next few days while his friends visited Hiro and when work was nearly done, Thomas met up with Hiro again and told him that tonight he would fix everything. Looking at the house, it doesn’t look like it’s towards completion.


Anyway, the Duke and Duchess gave their thanks to Thomas and he set off for Knapford station to see the Fat Controller, but Spencer trailed behind him knowing it was about Hiro. With the dialogue from Spencer wanting Hiro to be scrapped just screams this would be fit for a diesel character and made me realise, as I said earlier, that Spencer being the villain is unique on paper but not in execution because it wasn’t unique enough. So Spencer chased after Thomas and as they crossed the fenland bridge it broke taking Spencer along with it. Thomas promised to help him as he pulled into Knapford station and asked to speak to the Fat Controller who was having dinner with the Duke and Duchess at his house.


Thomas told them all about Hiro and to his surprise the Fat Controller and the Boxford’s knew about Hiro and how famous he was and questioned why he would ever scrap him, seriously if this was Stanley this would make a ton of sense. Hell Stanley would have a much better reason than Thomas for being a stupid idiot, seriously why after all these years would Thomas think he would scrap engines? He saved Oliver from scrap for god sake! As I said before, the TV series version is one thing, but the Railway Series side is another, I mean in that canon the Coffee pot engines were scrapped because they were terrible steamers. Stanley made more sense given that he was new to Sodor, I know I’ve been stressing this enough but this special had so much missed potential to be actually good.


After telling him, the Fat Controller told Thomas to send Hiro to the steamworks and there he was repaired and repainted and looking like a brand new steam engine again. After that both Thomas and Hiro rescued Spencer from his accident and the three engines had completed the summer house with Spencer apologising for his behaviour.


After that Thomas could see that Hiro was sad because he missed his homeland and so with arrangements made Hiro was given a farewell at Brendam docks with all the engines there and thus we come to the end of the special. The special would end with the song ‘Go, Go Thomas!’ the first song not to be sung by a children’s choir and was instead performed by Sam Blewitt, at least in the North American DVD release. It’s nice that they retired from the idea of using a children’s choir as I feel they were becoming quite bland with their singing, though I think that might be because of the lyrics that were written or the direction.


However if you’re from either Australia or the UK you would’ve been greeted by credits with screengrabs of the special and a very short version of the opening theme song. When I first saw this back in 2009 I was miffed because I was expecting the song, luckily it was a bonus feature on DVD, but it was a dumb change that was made for no reason.
 
OVERALL

Hero of the Rails, the first CGI special to showcase to the world what it can do for Thomas, and it did deliver but on terms of story, I would say for that department, I think it could’ve been better and I had given my reasons on why through my views of the movie. I do like it, it’s not bad but I wouldn’t say it was favourite. The special was for the most part a bit boring what with the constant back and forth of the engines sneaking past Spencer and all which really slowed down the pace.

As I said, and I think I’ll be in the minority of this opinion, but Spencer really wasn’t that unique because I see his role easily carried out by Diesel or anyone and even when watching Unlucky Tug’s video about S13, I disagree with him about Spencer’s fall from grace character arc and that you can make Diesel prideful about being a diesel engine and being stronger than him and all or D261 and with the same development that Spencer had gone through in this special it wouldn’t make that much of a difference. I already made my own version to justify what I think is a more unique way to have Spencer as the villain so I would just leave it as that. Spencer’s villainy was unique on paper but not that unique in execution. It’s the most common problem from this season, replace a character with a different one to go through the same situation and you will still get the same outcome. 

One of the positives that I have with this special is Hiro, a HIT era newbie with a backstory and a consistent character as well as splendid dynamic between him and Thomas. Togo Igawa did an outstanding job to give Hiro the wise old man voice for him and I love his acting for the character. He was the right choice for Hiro, and I love it for the fact that he will be returning as him in ‘Railway Stories’.
The other positive is of course the diverse use of camera angles and man it was a breath of fresh air to see them going all out with it to showcase the advantages of Thomas in CG. There are some camera angles that would be present in the show, including some tracking shots but it’s such an incredible disappointment that they didn’t carry on putting all of their efforts in the special into S13 and we just get lame, repetitive camera shots over and over and over again.
Hero of the Rails was just alright but it’s nothing too special. It’s far from the worst but not anywhere near the best. I think it had more potential to be better than what we really got.

OVERALL RATING
4/10
Now with that done and dusted, what's next to look over